Septic companies in Maryland
Maryland's septic permit is a state permit signed at a county desk: the rule makes the Secretary of the Environment the approving authority and your county the designee. The credential picture is mid-transition, with a Board licence written into statute and a registration standing in until it starts. And Maryland funds septic upgrades from the Bay Restoration Fund, paid for by the $60 annual fee already charged on your onsite system.
- Companies
- 196
- Counties
- 24
- With Google reviews
- 100
- Prime Plumbing4.8 ★76 Google reviewsGlen Burnie, Anne Arundel CountySeptic System InstallationSeptic PumpingSeptic Tank Pumping
- Legacy Septic & Excavation4.9 ★64 Google reviewsManchester, Carroll CountySewage BackupEmergency Septic ServiceSeptic System InstallationSoil Evaluation
- Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Greater Baltimore4.8 ★43 Google reviewsBaltimore, Baltimore CountyDrain Field Repair
- Young Septic Services4.9 ★29 Google reviewsWestminster, Carroll CountySeptic System InstallationSeptic InspectionSeptic Pumping
- Cossentino Septic Tank Pumping, Cleaning and Repair5.0 ★23 Google reviewsUpperco, Baltimore CountySeptic PumpingSeptic Tank PumpingSeptic Tank Cleaning
- Southern Shores Septic & Excavating5.0 ★23 Google reviewsCroom, Prince George's CountyBaffle ReplacementSewage BackupNew SystemPerc Test
- Tri-County Pump Service, Inc.4.7 ★23 Google reviewsBoonsboro, Washington CountySeptic System InstallationSoil EvaluationSeptic Inspection
- Jet Septic and Plumbing Services5.0 ★22 Google reviewsWestminster, Carroll CountySeptic System InstallationSeptic InspectionSeptic Pumping
- Bailey Bros. Plumbing & Drain Services5.0 ★21 Google reviewsGlen Burnie, Anne Arundel CountySeptic Tank Pumping
- Brothers' Johnson Septic Services4.8 ★19 Google reviewsPort Republic, Calvert County
- King & Sons Septic Service, LLC5.0 ★19 Google reviewsGaithersburg, Montgomery County
- Freeline Plumbing Services4.9 ★18 Google reviewsCapitol Heights, Prince George's CountyNew System
- Green's Septic & Excavation, LLC3.7 ★18 Google reviewsChestertown, Kent CountySeptic System InstallationSeptic PumpingSeptic Tank Pumping
- Chavis Septic Services4.9 ★16 Google reviewsForest Hill, Harford CountySeptic System InstallationReal Estate Septic InspectionSeptic InspectionSeptic Pumping
- Castro Home Services Inc4.8 ★15 Google reviewsAnnapolis, Anne Arundel County
- J. Calvin Wood Jr., INC.4.8 ★15 Google reviewsSt Leonard, Calvert County
- Jimmy's Septic LLC4.9 ★12 Google reviewsSunderland, Calvert County
- Statewide Septic & Backhoe3.3 ★12 Google reviewsDavidsonville, Anne Arundel County
- Fogle's Septic3.8 ★11 Google reviewsSykesville, Carroll CountySeptic System Installation
- Mid Atlantic Septic4.5 ★11 Google reviewsElkton, Cecil County
- Freestate Septic4.5 ★10 Google reviewsDavidsonville, Anne Arundel CountySeptic Pumping
- RT Services4.9 ★10 Google reviewsWilliamsport, Washington County
- A & D Septic Services0.0 ★9 Google reviewsDarlington, Harford County
- A Roy Fringer & Son5.0 ★9 Google reviewsWestminster, Carroll County
- D Barnes Excavating, LLC5.0 ★9 Google reviewsDrayden, St. Mary's CountySeptic System InstallationPerc TestPercolation Test
Who Regulates Septic Systems in Maryland
Sources: Maryland Department of the Environment. Checked 2026-09-18.
Maryland's septic permit is a state permit, signed at a county desk. That distinction sounds academic and it is not, because it explains why your county applies rules it did not write, and why two counties can run the same rulebook from different departments.
The rule names the authority in a way worth reading twice. Approving Authority means the Secretary of the Department of the Environment or the Secretary's designee opens in a new tab, and your county is that designee. MDE's Onsite Systems Division provides technical assistance and direction to county health departments and local approving authorities opens in a new tab.
The dividing line between a septic system and a treatment plant is a number. Small systems with a flow of less than 5,000 gallons per day are permitted by local health departments and generally classified as septic systems opens in a new tab. A house sits far below that.
One warning before you go looking for your office. Not every approving authority in Maryland is a health department: in several counties the work sits with environmental protection, land use, or environmental programmes instead. The table at the foot of this page names the office for each county rather than assuming.
Licenses and What to Check Before You Hire
Sources: Maryland Department of the Environment. Checked 2026-09-18.
Maryland is mid-transition here, and knowing that saves confusion when a contractor's paperwork says one thing and the statute says another. The law creates a licence, the licence is not yet being issued, and a registration is standing in for it.
The statute says an individual shall be licensed by the Board before the individual may provide on-site wastewater services in the State opens in a new tab, and on-site wastewater services means any activity associated with the design, installation, operation and maintenance, pumping, repair or property transfer inspection opens in a new tab. That definition is broad on purpose.
Until the Board implements its new licensing requirements and procedures, section 9-11A-15 requires any individual providing those services to register opens in a new tab, and that registration covers any septic installer, septic pumper, septic hauler, septic designer, property transfer inspector, plumber, and operation and maintenance provider opens in a new tab. So the word on a current card is registration, not licence.
The Department maintains a list of individuals who are registered to perform on-site wastewater disposal services, which local permitting authorities use opens in a new tab. Asking whether a contractor is on it is a fair question, and it is the same check your county will make.
On top of the registration, some work needs a certificate for that specific technology. MDE offers training through the Onsite Systems Division for individuals to gain certifications to install sand mound and other system types opens in a new tab. If you are being sold a sand mound or a best available technology unit, ask which certification the installer holds for it.
Two more instruments sit outside the Board. Every person in the business of removing and disposing of the contents of on-site sewage disposal systems shall obtain an annual permit from the Approving Authority opens in a new tab, which is a county permit rather than a state one. And a 2021 Act created new licensing requirements for people providing property transfer inspections opens in a new tab.
The soil work is not a private credential in Maryland at all. Site evaluations including percolation tests shall be conducted under the supervision of the Approving Authority opens in a new tab, and for the design the applicant arranges a professional engineer, an Environmental Health Specialist, or other qualified consultant as determined by that authority opens in a new tab. We hold no Maryland register of our own, so no listing here carries a verified credential for this state.
Permits, Inspections and Selling a Home
Sources: Maryland Department of the Environment; University of Maryland Extension. Checked 2026-09-18.
A person may not construct or attempt to construct an on-site sewage disposal system without first receiving a permit from the Approving Authority opens in a new tab, and no part of a system may be covered or used until it has been inspected and approved by that authority or by an approved third party opens in a new tab. Covered means backfilled, so that inspection is the last moment anyone can see the work.
On selling, we found no Maryland rule requiring a septic inspection at transfer. What the state regulates is who may perform one if it happens, which is a different thing. The 2021 legislation created licensing requirements for people providing those property transfer inspections opens in a new tab.
In practice the requirement usually comes from the lender rather than the law. Lenders may require a septic system inspection when you sell or refinance your home, and the seller is usually responsible for repair of a failing system opens in a new tab. Budget for that possibility rather than for a statutory duty.
Keeping a System Working
Sources: Maryland Department of the Environment; University of Maryland Extension; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Checked 2026-09-18.
Maryland binds the schedule only for the advanced units: the owner shall ensure a BAT system is inspected and has necessary operation and maintenance performed at a minimum of once per year opens in a new tab, and every BAT system sold in the State includes a two year operation and maintenance contract and a two year warranty opens in a new tab. For a conventional tank there is no mandatory interval: the permit carries MDE's recommendation that tanks be pumped at a frequency adequate to keep solids out of the drainfield opens in a new tab, and the extension service's figure is every three to five years opens in a new tab, in line with the EPA's three year inspection interval opens in a new tab.
Help Paying for Repairs
Sources: Maryland Department of the Environment; Bay Restoration Fund Advisory Committee; Maryland Department of Housing and Community Development; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Checked 2026-09-18.
Maryland has the strongest household septic money in this part of the country, and you are already paying into it. A $60 annual fee is collected from each user served by an onsite system, with total estimated programme income of $27 million per year opens in a new tab. That is the Bay Restoration Fund.
Who may apply is drawn wide, and it includes ordinary homeowners. Maryland residents, non-profits and business owners paying into the Bay Restoration Fund may be eligible for funding through the BRF septic system upgrade programme opens in a new tab. If you pay the fee, you are in the eligible group.
The queue is ordered, and the top of it is worth knowing. Priority is given to failing septic systems in Critical Areas, and funds can be provided for upgrades of existing systems to best available technology for nitrogen removal, or for the marginal cost of using it instead of conventional technology opens in a new tab.
Drainfields were brought in recently and the tiers are by income. Low income recipients may qualify for up to 100% funding and moderate income recipients up to $5,000 of eligible project costs opens in a new tab, and a low income owner is also eligible for a 50% grant toward the annual operation and maintenance cost beyond the initial period opens in a new tab.
Apply through your county, not to the state, and expect the money never to touch your bank account. The county or its coordinating administrative partner facilitates the grant process with the property owner for the installation opens in a new tab. As of 30 June 2025 the fund had paid for 17,184 best available technology upgrades across Maryland, 10,550 of them inside the Critical Areas opens in a new tab, so this is a programme with a long record rather than a pilot.
Two further routes are worth a call if the fund does not fit. Maryland Housing Rehabilitation Program loans are originated, packaged and closed by the Department of Housing and Community Development and its local partners opens in a new tab, and federal grant funds can help a nonprofit run a revolving loan fund for owner occupiers in an eligible rural area opens in a new tab.
Find Your Local Approving Authority
Maryland septic permits are issued by the local approving authority for your county, acting as the state's designee. Not all of them are health departments. Each entry below names the office for that county. Checked 2026-09-18.
| County | Environmental health office |
|---|---|
| Anne Arundel | Anne Arundel County Health Department opens in a new tabMDE's Local Approving Authorities page links this office and this domain for Anne Arundel, which is what puts aahealth.org on the allowlist. The septic desk is named on the page as the Sanitary Engineering Program, inside the Department of Health. The page title brands the office 'Anne Arundel County Health Department'; one line of body text calls it 'Anne Arundel County Department of Health'. · Anne Arundel County page |
| Baltimore | Baltimore County Department of Environmental Protection and Sustainability, Ground Water Management Section opens in a new tabNOT a health department: Baltimore County's approving authority is the Department of Environmental Protection and Sustainability (EPS), and the septic desk inside it is the Ground Water Management Section (GWM). TWO THINGS A WRITER MUST NOT MISS. (1) The FIPS in the target file, 24510, is Baltimore CITY's code; Baltimore County is 24005. The site page is titled 'Septic companies in Baltimore County, Maryland' so the office recorded here is the county's, but the page's only listing sits at a Baltimore city address, and the city is an independent jurisdiction whose approving authority is a different office, the Baltimore City Health Department at https://health.baltimorecity.gov/programs/environmental-health (fetched 2026-09-20, 200, titled 'Environmental Health | Baltimore City'). (2) Live local rule worth stating: the same page says that since July 1, 2023 the County no longer provides OSDS designs and only provides minimum design criteria, so a new or repaired system needs a licensed OSDS designer's design and a licensed OSDS installer to submit it. The MDE list writes the department name with an ampersand, 'Environmental Protection & Sustainability'; the county's own page spells it out. Re-keyed from 24510 to 24005 on 2026-09-20: 24510 is Baltimore City and this page is Baltimore County. The authority named here was already the county's. · Baltimore County page |
| Calvert | Calvert County Health Department opens in a new tabQuote is from the department's Septic Systems page, one level below the Environmental Health Services landing page that MDE links. The landing page carries the same sentence pattern only in a meta description, which is not body prose, so the septic page was used instead. calverthealth.org is the domain MDE's Local Approving Authorities page links for Calvert. The department serves this path over both http and https. · Calvert County page |
| Carroll | Carroll County Health Department opens in a new tabCarroll's health department is hosted on the state's own domain, health.maryland.gov/carroll, not a county domain. The septic desk is the Bureau of Environmental Health; its director and address are on the Environmental-Health page. The quote is from the Sewage Disposal page and is written generically about local health departments rather than naming Carroll, so the county identification rests on the URL path and the page's own section menu. · Carroll County page |
| Charles | Charles County Department of Health opens in a new tabThe office names itself 'Charles County Department of Health' in its own page title and in body prose on the Bay Restoration page; MDE's list calls it 'Charles County Health Department'. Recorded as the office names itself. The septic desk is the Division of Environmental Health Services, which the page splits into MDE programs (environmental) and MDH programs (food and community hygiene). charlescountyhealth.org is the domain MDE links. · Charles County page |
| Garrett | Garrett County Health Department opens in a new tabThe department's Sewage Disposal Systems page is unusually detailed, walking through perc test, soil evaluation, permit, installation and backfill inspection. It states that before a dwelling may be built or a mobile home moved onto any property in Garrett County a permit to install a sewage disposal system must be obtained from Environmental Health Services. garretthealth.org is the domain MDE links. · Garrett County page |
| Harford | Harford County Health Department opens in a new tabThe department's Septic Systems page is a link list with no body prose, and the Environmental Health landing page carries only a fee-change notice, so the quote comes from the Percolation Testing page on the same site. Harford runs a Wet Season perc testing window (typically February to April) that opens and closes on measured water table levels. harfordcountyhealth.com is the domain MDE links. · Harford County page |
| Howard | Howard County Health Department opens in a new tabThe health department sits inside the county government site rather than on its own domain. Its Environmental Health page spells out the delegation in full: the Howard County Health Department has delegated authority under the Environment Article and has been designated the Approving Authority for COMAR 26.04.02, 26.04.03, 26.04.04, 26.04.05 and 26.08.09. That text sits inside a collapsed accordion panel, so the quote recorded here is taken from the visible Well and Septic Program page instead. Separate and easy to confuse: Public Works runs a Shared Septic Division for community systems. · Howard County page |
| Montgomery | Montgomery County Department of Permitting Services opens in a new tabNOT a health department. MDE's list names the approving authority 'Montgomery County Land Development Division', but that phrase appears nowhere on the county's own septic or permitting pages, which brand every one of them 'Department of Permitting Services' (DPS). Recorded as the county names it, with MDE's division name given here. The quote is a contiguous opening span of the Overview paragraph; the full sentence runs past 35 words. Soils testing is seasonal: the 2026 Wet Season was closed for insufficient water table levels at the time of checking. · Montgomery County page |
| Prince George's | Prince George's County Health Department opens in a new tab · Prince George's County page |
| Queen Anne's | Queen Anne's County Health Department opens in a new tabHosted on the state domain, health.maryland.gov/qahealth. MDE's list calls it 'Queen Anne's County Department of Health'; its own pages say 'Queen Anne's County Health Department (QACHD)'. Recorded as the office names itself. The quote drops a leading 'The' to stay inside the 35 word limit, and the served HTML has a stray space inside 'Maryland' at this point which normalisation removes. The Environmental Health landing page describes the septic desk as the Sewer Program, and the department takes property septic and well record requests by email. · Queen Anne's County page |
| St. Mary's | St. Mary's County Health Department opens in a new tabsmchd.org is the domain MDE's Local Approving Authorities page links for St. Mary's. The page says the Environmental Health Division works closely with Land Use and Growth Management, the Metropolitan Commission and Animal Control, so a septic applicant in this county may be dealing with more than one office. · St. Mary's County page |
| Washington | Washington County Health Department opens in a new tabOne page carries the whole environmental health programme, septic included: it states that septic systems are used for sewage disposal where public collection is not available and that percolation tests are conducted to evaluate soils for a potential on-site septic system. washcohealth.org is the domain MDE links. Wrong-state trap: Washington County exists in more than thirty states, so confirm any search result names Maryland. · Washington County page |
| Wicomico | Wicomico County Health Department opens in a new tabThe septic desk here is called the Environmental Protection Division, not an environmental health division, and it also handles wells, subdivision plats, plumbing, perc tests and open burning. wicomicohealth.org is the domain MDE links. · Wicomico County page |
| Worcester | Worcester County Department of Environmental Programs opens in a new tabNOT a health department: Worcester's approving authority is county government, the Department of Environmental Programs, based in the Government Center in Snow Hill. MDE's list shortens the name to 'Worcester County Environmental Programs'; the department's own page calls itself the Department of Environmental Programs. It also carries delegations from the Department of Natural Resources, which none of the other 18 counties here do. · Worcester County page |
Questions People Ask
Who issues my septic permit in Maryland?
Legally the state, in practice your county. The rule defines the Approving Authority as the Secretary of the Environment or the Secretary's designee, and your county is that designee. Systems under 5,000 gallons a day are permitted by local health departments, which covers a house.
Is my septic contractor licensed?
Registered, for now. The statute creates a Board licence, but until the Board implements licensing, anyone providing on-site wastewater services must register instead. That covers installers, pumpers, haulers, designers, property transfer inspectors, plumbers and maintenance providers, and MDE keeps the list your county uses.
Can I get help paying for a new system?
Very likely, through the Bay Restoration Fund, which is funded by the $60 annual fee you already pay on an onsite system. Maryland residents paying into the fund may be eligible, priority goes to failing systems in Critical Areas, and low income owners can qualify for up to 100% of a drainfield project.
How do I apply for that money?
Through your county rather than to the state. The county or its coordinating administrative partner runs the grant process with you, and payments go to the contractor rather than to you. The fund has paid for 17,184 upgrades as of 30 June 2025.
Do I need an inspection to sell my house?
We found no Maryland rule requiring one at transfer. What the state regulates is who may perform one, through a licence created in 2021. In practice the lender usually drives it, and the seller is usually responsible for repairing a failing system.
Sources
- COMAR 26.04.02.01 Definitions opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Onsite Systems - On-Site Systems Division opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Frequently Asked Questions opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- MD Environmental Code Title 9 Subtitle 11A opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- MD Environmental Code Title 9 Subtitle 11A opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- State Board of On-Site Wastewater Professionals opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- State Board of On-Site Wastewater Professionals opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Registration to Perform On-Site Wastewater Services in Maryland opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.02 General Provisions opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Onsite Systems Training opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.06 Non-Conventional On-Site Sewage Disposal Systems opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.02 General Provisions opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.03 On-Site Sewage Disposal Permits opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.02 General Provisions opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- On-site Sewage Disposal System - Information for Property Transfer Inspectors opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- A Guide to Septic Systems and Maintenance (FS-1105) opens in a new tabUniversity of Maryland Extension · checked 2026-09-20
- How to Care for Your Septic System | US EPA opens in a new tabU.S. Environmental Protection Agency · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.07 Best Available Technology for Removal of Nitrogen (BAT) opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.07 Best Available Technology for Removal of Nitrogen (BAT) opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- COMAR 26.04.02.03 On-Site Sewage Disposal Permits opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- A Guide to Septic Systems and Maintenance (FS-1105) opens in a new tabUniversity of Maryland Extension · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Septic System Upgrade Program (SSUP) Guidance FY27 opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Septic System Upgrade Program (SSUP) Guidance FY27 opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Septic System Upgrade Program (SSUP) Guidance FY27 opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Septic System Upgrade Program (SSUP) Guidance FY27 opens in a new tabMaryland Department of the Environment · checked 2026-09-20
- Bay Restoration Fund Advisory Committee Annual Status Report, January 2026 opens in a new tabBay Restoration Fund Advisory Committee · checked 2026-09-20
- Housing Rehabilitation | Maryland Department of Housing and Community Development opens in a new tabMaryland Department of Housing and Community Development · checked 2026-09-20
- Funding for Septic Systems | US EPA opens in a new tabU.S. Environmental Protection Agency · checked 2026-09-20
Cities in Maryland
- Pasadena 9
- Elkton 7
- Mechanicsville 5
- Westminster 5
- Baltimore 4
- Glen Burnie 4
- Sykesville 4
- Capitol Heights 3
- Church Hill 3
- Davidsonville 3
- Gaithersburg 3
- Hagerstown 3
- Huntingtown 3
- New Windsor 3
- Reisterstown 3
- Aberdeen 2
- Avenue 2
- Bel Air South 2
- Bishopville 2
- Cambridge 2
- Centreville 2
- Crownsville 2
- Edgewood 2
- Forest Hill 2
- Frederick 2
- Hollywood 2
- Jarrettsville 2
- Lusby 2
- Millersville 2
- North Potomac 2
- Owings 2
- Severna Park 2
- Silver Spring 2
- Annapolis 1
- Beltsville 1
- Bensville 1
- Boonsboro 1
- Bowie 1
- Brandywine 1
- Bryans Road 1
- Charlotte Hall 1
- Chestertown 1
- Cordova 1
- Crofton 1
- Croom 1
- Darlington 1
- Deale 1
- Delmar 1
- Dickerson 1
- Drayden 1
- Earleville 1
- Easton 1
- Fallston 1
- Freeland 1
- Frostburg 1
- Glenelg 1
- Glenn Dale 1
- Grantsville 1
- Hancock 1
- Harwood 1
- Havre de Grace 1
- Herald Harbor 1
- Hughesville 1
- Ijamsville 1
- Ilchester 1
- Keedysville 1
- Keymar 1
- Kingsville 1
- La Plata 1
- Laytonsville 1
- Leonardtown 1
- Lonaconing 1
- Manchester 1
- McHenry 1
- Monkton 1
- Mountain Lake Park 1
- Mt Airy 1
- North Beach 1
- Oakland 1
- Parole 1
- Parsonsburg 1
- Perry Hall 1
- Perryman 1
- Pittsville 1
- Port Republic 1
- Prince Frederick 1
- Ridgely 1
- Rockville 1
- Salisbury 1
- Sharpsburg 1
- St Leonard 1
- St Michaels 1
- Stevensville 1
- Sunderland 1
- Taneytown 1
- Temple Hills 1
- Towson 1
- Union Bridge 1
- Upperco 1
- Valley Lee 1
- Waldorf 1
- Walkersville 1
- White Marsh 1
- Whiteford 1
- Williamsport 1
Counties in Maryland
- Anne Arundel County, MD
- Carroll County, MD
- Harford County, MD
- St. Mary's County, MD
- Calvert County, MD
- Baltimore County, MD
- Montgomery County, MD
- Prince George's County, MD
- Washington County, MD
- Cecil County, MD
- Charles County, MD
- Frederick County, MD
- Wicomico County, MD
- Garrett County, MD
- Queen Anne's County, MD
- Dorchester County, MD
- Talbot County, MD
- Worcester County, MD
- Howard County, MD
How these are ranked
By verification score, out of 100, across six checks published in full on how we rank. No company paid to appear and none can pay to rank higher. The score counts records and is not a judgment about workmanship.